Strengths and weaknesses of aptamers in comparison with antibodies
Criteria | Aptamers | Antibodies |
---|---|---|
Size | 5–15 kDa | 150–180 kDa |
• Target accessibility | High | Low |
• Minimal target size | 60 Da | 600 Da |
• Tissue/tumor penetration | High | Low |
• Clearance rate | Rapid | Slow |
Basic composition | Nucleotides | Amino acids |
• Resistance to harsh environment conditions (pH and temperature) | High | Low |
• Shelf-life | Long | Limited |
• Versatility to chemical | High | Limited |
• Nuclease degradation | Sensitive; limited half-life in vivo (unmodified) | Resistant; long half-life in vivo |
Therapeutic efficacy | ||
• Affinity and specificity | KD, nano/pico | KD, nano/pico |
• Immunogenicity | Low/none | High |
• Modulation of target activity | Yes | Yes |
• Fc-mediated effector | No | Yes |
Discovery | ||
• Time | In vitro SELEX, 2–8 weeks | In vivo biological process, 6 |
Production | ||
• Scale up | Easy | Hard |
• Batch to batch variation | None | High |
KD values: dissociation constants